Bird’s Eye View: The Danger of Flock Camera Surveillance

Opinion by Minnie Youngblood/Staff
Graphic by Angel Lopez/Staff

With more than 120,000 operating cameras nationwide and over 50 in the Tyler area, Flock Safety claims its mission is to build technology that helps communities deter crime, respond to emergencies, and investigate safety incidents. These cameras are intended to function as automated license plate readers (LPRs), but their constant surveillance raises privacy and security concerns that cannot be ignored.  

Both UT Tyler students and the American public should oppose the growing use of Flock Safety cameras.  

Earlier this year, the public learned that UT Tyler has a contract with Flock Safety that will continue until 2028. This partnership should alarm both students and Tyler residents.

A major issue with this technology is its violation of the Fourth Amendment. The amendment protects people from unreasonable searches and seizures by the government. Essentially, it’s the right of a person to be secure in a public and private capacity. However, with Flock’s continuous surveillance, anyone driving on a road where there are cameras will have their license plate and movements recorded. Flock claims that this is not a violation because data is only pulled when it relates to a case or crime, but this begs the question of what constitutes a crime and who makes that decision. A person wrongfully accused of criminal behavior could have their every movement tracked with the click of a button. 

Another concern with this technology is not just the data it collects but who has access to that data. According to Flock, only law enforcement users in approved roles can access LPR cameras strictly for case-related data, meaning no open searching. However, this claim has already been proven false when officers were caught tracking specific individuals using Flock cameras. In the nearby Lufkin, Texas, Police Department, an officer pleaded guilty to 100 counts of misuse after conducting over 25,000 unauthorized Flock searches targeting his ex-girlfriend and her family. This is just one of at least 50 officers nationwide who have been caught abusing these databases to monitor personal relationships. Constant surveillance technology such as this should not be accessible to anyone regardless of their job title.  

Those in support of Flock cameras argue that the technology helps solve crime; therefore, continuous surveillance is necessary. However, the data behind these claims is severely lacking. Flock CEO Garrett Langley claimed that the company had solved over 1 million cases last year yet investigative reports from CBS News show that these claims come from un-audited, self-reported estimates. The company has also had multiple disputed claims when it comes to crime investigation as well as internal inconsistencies about the number of cases solved per day. While there is little proof they actually assist with crime-solving, we do know the cameras continue to monitor the public regardless.  

Because of their violation of the Fourth Amendment and susceptibility to misuse, Americans should oppose the growing placement of Flock cameras and ask the question: Are these cameras truly solving crime or creating more opportunities for it?

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


5 × five =